I thought that my vagina was just abnormally small or tight They played a huge part in my life. sex with my boyfriend for a couple of times bt it seems my vaginal is just too small nd his dick can't go in, pls wat should I do? You wouldn't think that if you look at how shallow (young) women are today. I have a small vagina, my boyfriend has an averagely sized **** - in some. The preference for big dicks is purely for bragging rights.. 16 years old, only 5 inches in length - So I'm confused.do guys like a tight vagina or not?